| Willy Krosnyak (FOR) | Yes, GK more valuable | |
| Paul Roseblade (AYR) | Yes, GK more valuable | |
| Daniel Fitzgerald (ANN) | NO, a MA is more valuable | |
| Colin Scott (DUM) | NO, a MA is more valuable | |
| Mark Boland (DUU) | Yes, GK more valuable | At 30+ SL without a shadow of a doubt |
| Steve Gregory (COV) | Yes, GK more valuable | |
| Roy Rolsten (STI) | Yes, GK more valuable | To me a GK is worth more |
| Daniel Roseblade (DFA) | About the same | |
| Steve Turner (ALO) | About the same | One can score goals, one can save goals. So about the same. |
| Lee Elkins (CB) | Yes, GK more valuable | IMHO (and I've read the code), GK is more valuable. |
| Ricky Hawthorn (STE) | Yes, GK more valuable | |
| Dave Smyth (HEA) | Yes, GK more valuable | |
| Mark Creasey (STJ) | Yes, GK more valuable | |
| Paul Cockayne (EF) | Yes, GK more valuable | MAs can win games but a great GK can win a season for you. |
| Marc Legowski (CLY) | Yes, GK more valuable | |
| Josh Fitzgerald (INV) | Yes, GK more valuable | Surely this is a no-brainer. Two SL30+ GK is the difference between promotion and relegation. You can easily keep a clean sheet while still giving away 10 shots. |
| Rob Lye (ROS) | Yes, GK more valuable | |
| Andrew Foss-Grant (MOT) | Yes, GK more valuable | Without a doubt the most valuable player on the pitch! |
| Cameron Archibald (ARB) | Yes, GK more valuable | |
| Bill Ramsay (RAN) | Yes, GK more valuable | |
| Eduard Habermann (DEE) | Yes, GK more valuable | Logically a MA, but I'd pay double currently for a 2nd top GK. #vitaltosucceed |
| James Tucker (RR) | Yes, GK more valuable | Keepers win leagues, MA's win matches |
| Tapani Olkku (GM) | Yes, GK more valuable | On equal SL; the GK will save 60% of the MA's shots, if he gets shots... if no-one gets a single shot the whole match, it does not matter and you might as well have your MA in goal and your GK at the shops buying a new pair of gloves! |
| James White (MON) | Yes, GK more valuable | |
| Matthew White (SM) | About the same | |
| Les Lithgo (HAM) | Yes, GK more valuable | Auction 3: lot 2 (GK) will likely go for higher than lot 1 (MA) |
| Arnold Yzermans (QOS) | Yes, GK more valuable | |
| Matt Cooper (ALB) | Yes, GK more valuable | |